5406 MARY AvenueFernandina Beach, FL 32034

Rare Double Lot Opportunity in Historic American Beach — Build Your Coastal Retreat. Discover a truly exceptional opportunity at the end of Mary Avenue in Historic American Beach on Amelia Island — a rare double lot offering privacy, flexibility, and the chance to create something truly special. Tucked away in a quiet setting, this expansive homesite backs to a serene pond and is framed by a beautiful natural tree canopy, creating a peaceful, Old Florida backdrop that is increasingly hard to find. Just a short stroll to the beach, this location offers the perfect balance of seclusion and coastal convenience. With two lots combined, the possibilities are elevated — design a custom primary residence, a luxury vacation home, or an investment property with added space and privacy. Opportunities like this are limited in American Beach, where charm, history, and proximity to the ocean continue to drive strong demand. Valuable improvements are already in place, including no impact fees and available county water and sewer connections with fees paid — saving both time and upfront costs as you begin the building process. Located just minutes from Amelia Island’s pristine beaches, the Ritz-Carlton, and the shops and dining of historic Fernandina Beach, this property places you at the center of one of Northeast Florida’s most sought-after coastal destinations. Rarely does a double lot with this setting, location, and readiness to build become available. This is your opportunity to create a home that reflects your vision and truly Love Where You Live. Pond belongs to Ocean Village HOA